00 flour(left) versus all-purpose flour(right)

The perfect pizza begins not with the toppings or sauce, but the crust, and the crust’s secret lies in the flour used to create it. Two of the most widely used types for making pizza are ’00’ flour and all-purpose flour. But which flour is truly the best for achieving great pizza dough?

This article will uncover the mystery of these different types of flour, dissecting their unique characteristics, advantages, and disadvantages. By the end of this gastronomic journey, you will have the knowledge to select the perfect flour for your next pizza creation.

History and Origin

Flour, in its many forms, has been a staple of human diets for thousands of years. All-purpose flour and 00 flour, while different, share common roots in this history.

All-purpose flour is an invention of convenience, developed to suit the broad baking needs of American households. As the name suggests, it’s designed for ‘all purposes,’ from baking bread to whipping up a batch of cookies.

On the other hand, 00 flour, also known as doppio zero flour, has its roots in Italian cooking. The ’00’ refers to the fineness of the milling process. Italian millers grade their flour by the particles’ fineness resulting in types ranging from one, zero, to double zero, with 00 being the finest. This flour is often used in Italian delicacies like pasta and pizza.

Understanding Flour Types

sacks of flour and a bowl of flour

Flour is finely ground grain, usually wheat, that is a staple in many different types of cuisine. The ‘type of flour’ essentially refers to the specific kind of wheat used and the processing methods it undergoes.

All-purpose flour, as its name suggests, is designed for versatility. This everyday flour is a blend of hard and soft wheat, offering a middle-of-the-road protein content, typically around 10-12 percent. This protein transforms into gluten when mixed with water, providing the structure and chewy texture in baked goods.

On the other hand, ’00’ or ‘doppio zero’ flour is an Italian flour popularly used for fresh pasta and pizzas. It’s made from soft wheat and has a lower gluten content. The ’00’ refers to the fineness of the milling, akin to the texture of baby powder or talcum powder, offering a distinctive soft and silky texture.

Diving Deeper: 00 Flour

00 flour

00 flour, also known as ‘double zero flour’ or ‘pizza flour’, holds a revered position in Italian cooking, particularly in creating thin-crust pizzas cooked in high temperatures of wood-fired ovens. Its fine consistency allows it to absorb a little water, making for a sticky dough that’s easily stretched, resulting in a thin, crispy crust that’s characteristic of authentic pizza.

One disadvantage of 00 flour is its lower gluten content, which means a less chewy texture compared to higher-gluten flours. Additionally, its fine texture might make it a bit more difficult to handle for novice pizza makers.

Contrary to popular belief, 00 flour doesn’t have a higher protein content. The protein content is typically similar to all-purpose flour or even less.

The shelf life of 00 flour is comparable to other types of flour, lasting up to a year when stored in a cool, dry place, but it’s always best to check the expiration date on the packaging.

Diving Deeper: All-Purpose Flour

All-purpose flour

All-purpose flour is a blend of hard wheat (higher protein, higher gluten) and soft wheat flour (lower protein, lower gluten), striking a perfect balance that makes it a good choice for a variety of recipes from plain white bread to pie crusts.

One advantage of all-purpose flour is its higher gluten content, which gives baked goods their structure and chewy texture. This makes it an excellent choice for bread recipes where a sturdy crumb structure is desirable.

However, the downside to all-purpose flour is that it might not provide the best result for recipes that require a specific type of flour, like a cake that needs cake flour or a pizza that might benefit from 00 flour. It’s a jack of all trades but master of none, so to speak.

Despite these drawbacks, all-purpose flour’s high protein content and versatility make it a staple in most American kitchens. 

Head-to-Head Comparison: 00 Flour vs All-Purpose Flour

When comparing 00 flour and all-purpose flour, the main difference lies in their gluten content and how they react with water. Despite a similar protein content, 00 flour’s fine milling means it requires less water to create a cohesive dough, resulting in a crispy crust with a tender crumb when baked at high temperatures. All-purpose flour, with its higher gluten content, absorbs much water and can yield a chewy crust, which can be great for certain types of pizza like a New York-style pizza.

As for substituting one for the other, it’s possible but will impact the texture and flavor of your pizza crust. Using all-purpose flour instead of 00 flour might make your crust chewy than crispy. Conversely, using 00 flour in place of all-purpose might result in a crust with less bite and more crunch.

In the United States, there’s no direct equivalent to 00 flour, but strong bread flour or even pastry flour could offer similar results.

Nutritional Values

Nutritionally, 00 flour and all-purpose flour are quite similar. They both come from wheat, so they share a similar nutritional profile. A standard serving of either flour will provide a good amount of carbohydrates, along with some protein.

However, because 00 flour is more finely ground, it tends to have slightly fewer nutrients than all-purpose flour. The finer milling process can remove more of the wheat’s bran and germ where much of the fiber and micronutrients are stored.

Meanwhile, all-purpose flour is often enriched in the United States, meaning nutrients like iron and B vitamins are added back in after the milling process.

Remember that while the difference in nutrient content is small, it might matter more to those with specific dietary needs or restrictions.

At a Glance: 00 Flour vs All-Purpose Flour

To help you understand the key differences between 00 flour and all-purpose flour, here’s a handy table that breaks down their characteristics, uses, and nutritional values. This comparison should help you decide which flour might be best for your baking needs, whether you’re kneading pizza dough, preparing fresh pasta, or baking bread.

Key Differences and Similarities Between 00 Flour and All-Purpose Flour

Characteristic 00 Flour All-Purpose Flour
Origin Italy United States
Type of Wheat Soft Wheat Blend of Hard and Soft Wheat
Protein Content Lower (8-12%) Higher (10-12%)
Gluten Content Lower Higher
Texture Finer, similar to baby powder Coarser, more granular
Best Used For Thin-crust pizzas, fresh pasta Bread, thick crust pizzas, pastries
Absorption Absorbs less water, quickly Absorbs more water
Shelf Life Up to a year if stored properly Up to a year if stored properly
Nutritional Value Similar to all-purpose, slightly fewer nutrients due to finer milling Often enriched with nutrients in the United States
Table of comparison

The Flour in the World of Pizza

Choosing the right flour is an art in itself, especially when it comes to making pizza. After all, the pizza’s soul is in its crust. The type of flour you use can greatly influence the final product’s taste, texture, and look.LE

The protein content of the flour plays a significant role in defining the crust’s character. The ‘strong’ flours, such as bread flour, have a higher protein content and thus, higher gluten, ideal for a chewy, robust crust. However, if you prefer a crust with a crispy exterior and soft, airy interior, a ‘soft’ flour-like 00 flour could be your best choice due to its lower protein content.

Now, you might be wondering, “Can we achieve the best of both worlds?” The answer lies in blending the flours. Yes, you heard it right! A blend of 00 flour and all-purpose flour can give you a crust that strikes a perfect balance between crispy and chewy. However, remember, the proportions may require some experimentation to find your perfect blend.

Answering Common Queries

Many budding pizza enthusiasts often wonder, “What’s the best flour for pizza?” As we’ve explored, the answer depends on the kind of pizza you’re aiming for. For an authentic Neapolitan-style pizza, 00 flour is traditionally used. However, if you’re after a New York-style pizza, high-gluten flour like all-purpose or bread flour is the way to go.

But then, “Why use 00 flour instead of all-purpose?” For thin and crispy pizzas, 00 flour is generally the better choice. Its fine grind and lower gluten content allow for a thinner, more delicate crust that crisps up beautifully in a hot oven.

Yet, if you find yourself out of 00 flour, you might wonder, “Can you substitute OO flour for all-purpose?” While it is possible, the end result will have a chewier texture and may require more hydration, as all-purpose flour absorbs more water.

The common question about the American equivalent of 00 flour is interesting. While there’s no direct equivalent, pastry flour or finely milled cake flour can offer a similar texture but with varying protein content.

To conclude, choosing the perfect flour comes down to understanding what you want in your pizza crust. The “best” flour is the one that suits your taste, whether it’s the tender crispness of a 00 flour crust or the satisfying chew of an all-purpose flour crust.

Storage and Shelf Life

tip over jar of flour

When it comes to storage, both all-purpose and 00 flour have a similar shelf life. When stored properly in a cool, dry place, both types of flour can last up to a year.

However, once opened, it’s best to use the flour within a few months for the best result. If you don’t bake often, consider storing your flour in the refrigerator or freezer to extend its shelf life. Make sure it’s well sealed to prevent moisture and odors from affecting its quality.

A Look at Specific Pizza Styles

Now, let’s see how these flours fare in specific pizza styles. New York-style pizza, famous for its chewy texture and big, foldable slices, typically uses high-gluten flours, like all-purpose or bread flour. The high protein content of these flours creates a robust gluten network that can hold up to large slices and generous toppings.

On the other side of the coin, the traditional Neapolitan pizza, known for its thin and slightly puffy crust with charred spots, generally uses 00 flour. The fine texture and lower gluten content make for a dough that’s easy to stretch thinly and cooks quickly in high-temperature, wood-fired ovens.

As for creating a pizza dough that doesn’t stick, the secret lies more in your dough handling and the baking surface than the type of flour. However, using 00 flour might give you a slight advantage due to its finer texture.

Take Aways

The choice between 00 flour and all-purpose flour ultimately depends on your personal preference and the style of pizza you aim to create. While 00 flour might bring you closer to the thin, crispy crust of an Italian pizzeria, all-purpose flour can deliver the chewy satisfaction of a slice of New York pizza.

Related Articles


American Flour vs Italian Flour: Understanding the Differences and Their Applications

emmer flour sack and einkorn flour sack

Emmer Flour VS Einkorn Flour: Which Ancient Grains Is Better?

00 Flour vs Bread Flour: What’s The Key Difference?

All-purpose Flour VS Plain Flour

All-Purpose Flour VS Plain Flour: Which One Is The Best?