square cut pizza with a pizza cutter

Making the perfect pizza crust can be a tricky process, and over-proofing dough is one of the most common mistakes made by novice bakers. But is over-proofed dough safe to eat? The answer depends on several factors, including the amount of yeast in your recipe and how long you let your dough proof. In this article, we’ll look at what over-proofing means and when it’s safe to eat over-proofed dough.

What is an over-proofed dough?

Over-proofed dough is a type of dough that has over-risen, meaning it has been allowed to rise too long. This is a result of a long fermentation process, it occurs when yeast ferments far too long or when there is an excessive amount of yeast are used in the recipe.

What is fermentation?


Fermentation is a process in which microorganisms, such as yeast and bacteria, break down carbohydrates into simpler molecules like alcohol or acid. This breakdown of carbohydrates creates carbon dioxide and ethanol, both of which are used to leaven doughs and create flavor in fermented foods. Fermentation also helps preserve food over long periods of time by preventing the growth of harmful bacteria. In baking, fermentation is key for creating light and airy breads with great flavor.

How the amount of yeast affects the process of fermentation?

yeast, fresh and dry

The amount of yeast used in doughs can have a significant impact on the fermentation process. Too much yeast can lead to over-fermentation, resulting in air bubbles that are larger than desired and a weakened gluten structure which can cause dense and heavy breads. On the other hand, too little yeast may not provide enough carbon dioxide production to properly leaven the dough springs.

How over-proofing weakens gluten structure

When over-proofing occurs, the gluten network that is responsible for giving bread its structure and texture can become weakened. This happens because over-fermentation breaks down the proteins in flour, which results in a less elastic dough and an over-rise of air bubbles. As a result, over-proofed doughs will often produce loaves of bread with dense textures and excessive gas production due to increased fermentation activity.

The role of lactic acid bacteria in baking processes with over proofed dough

The role of lactic acid bacteria in baking processes is an important factor to consider when creating the perfect loaf. Lactic acid bacteria are responsible for producing carbon dioxide and other acids which help leaven over-proofed doughs, resulting in a lighter and more flavorful bread. In addition, these bacteria can also affect the texture, taste, and shelf life. Understanding how lactic acid bacteria contribute to over-proofing can help bakers create delicious loaves that stay fresh longer.

What are the role of enzymes in over-proofing?

Enzymes are proteins that catalyze biochemical reactions, allowing them to take place at much faster rates than they would occur naturally. In over-proofed dough, enzymes break down the gluten structure of the dough and release phytic acid from within its cells. This causes an increase in phytic acid content and contributes to the over-proofing process.

phytic acid molecular structure

What is phytic acid? What is its role on over proofing?

Phytic acid, also known as phytate, is an organic compound found naturally in certain grains and legumes. It binds to minerals such as iron, zinc, and calcium which can interfere with the absorption of these nutrients. Over-proofed doughs have been found to contain high levels of phytic acid which can further aggravate symptoms in people with celiac disease.

Celiac disease sufferers, gluten-sensitive people BEWARE!

man saying no to bread

Celiac disease sufferers also called celiac sprue people with Non-celiac gluten sensitivity should be aware that over proofing of doughs could trigger a reaction due to the presence of baker’s yeasts. Over-fermented doughs contain higher levels of gluten proteins than those that are not over proofed and, as a result, can act as an irritant for those with celiac disease. This is because over proofing increases the amount of yeast present in the dough, which can cause an inflammatory reaction in those with celiac disease. Additionally, over-proofing will result in more fermentation activity, leading to greater amounts of lactic acid bacteria and other compounds that may also trigger a reaction. To reduce the risk of triggering a reaction from over-proofed doughs, it is important for people with celiac disease to monitor the amount yeast and time used during fermentation to ensure dough is not over proofed. It is also important to choose recipes that require less yeast or longer fermentation times since this will reduce the amount of over-fermentation and lower the likelihood of triggering a reaction.

Difference between over-proof and under-proof

Under-Proofed Dough

Under-proofed dough is characterized by its dense, heavy texture. As with all breads, under-proofed dough has been given time to rise—but not enough time. Since the yeast didn’t have enough time to do its job, the fermentation process was incomplete and the gas pockets within the dough were not fully developed. This results in a denser, heavier loaf that lacks flavor and can be difficult to digest.

Over-Proofed Dough

Over-proofed dough is characterized by its gummy texture and lack of flavor. This occurs when too much gas has built up within the dough during its proofing period; this extra gas causes an excessive amount of gluten development, resulting in a tough and gummy loaf with little to no flavor.

The key to avoiding both under- and over-proofed dough is proper timing and temperature control. Bakers should keep an eye on their dough during its rising period; when it has doubled in size (or tripled for sourdough), it is ready for shaping and baking. Bakers need to make sure that their proofing area is at least 80°F (27°C); any colder than this will slow down or even stop yeast activity completely!

Properly fermented dough

Properly fermented dough should be smooth, elastic, and risen in volume with a domed shape. Look for tiny bubbles on the surface of the dough as a sign that there is ample aeration inside, giving it liveliness when you do the jiggle test. The key to fermenting dough properly is to give it enough time, at the right temperature and humidity.

To avoid over-fermenting your dough

If you want to avoid over-fermentation, the easiest way is to use less yeast in your recipes and opt for a longer fermentation time. This will give the yeast more time to do its job without over-fermenting the dough. Additionally, avoiding high temperatures can help prevent over-fermentation.

The benefits of using cold fermentation

To avoid over-fermenting your dough, you may want to consider using cold fermentation. This process involves slowing down the fermentation process by utilizing lower temperatures during the rise time of your dough. This helps create a longer fermentation time and allows for more flavor development while preventing over-fermentation and excessive gas production.

It’s also important to pay attention to how much time you give the dough for its first rise – too little or too much can affect the resulting bread.

What happens if you don’t give the dough enough time to rise?

If dough is not given enough time to rise, the resulting bread will be dense and heavy due to a weakened gluten structure. This can occur when proofing occurs too quickly or when the amount of yeast used is too much for the amount of dough. The over-fermentation process creates air bubbles, and if these bubbles are allowed to over expand in the dough, the gluten proteins become over stretched and weaken. If this happens, the dough cannot hold onto these air bubbles during baking, leading to heavy loafs with little oven spring.

Therefore, it is important to ensure that the dough is given enough time to rise in order to create a lighter texture in your bread and good oven spring. A great way to do this without having to wait long periods of time is bulk fermentation with wild yeasts which can reduce over proofing significantly while also adding some great flavor profiles.

How to know if dough is over-proof and what to do?

How to know if over-proofing has taken place?

Visually, signs of over-fermentation are as fallows;


Another best way to tell if you have over or under proofed your dough is by testing the gluten proteins. If the gluten proteins are over-developed, the dough will be over-proofed and will result in a dense and heavy bread.

On the other hand, if the gluten proteins are under-developed, the dough will be under-proofed and will produce a loaf with a crumb that is too open and airy.

How do you do that? To test the gluten proteins in your dough, simply take a small sample of dough and stretch it out between your fingers. If the dough stretches easily without breaking, then it is well-developed and can be used for baking. However, if the dough breaks easily or does not stretch at all, then it needs more time to proof.

Another easy way is use the “finger poke test” to determine if over proofing has taken place. If the dough does not spring back when poked with a finger, over proofing has occurred.

After being cook, visually an over-proof dough are as fallows;


Best thing to do when over proofing occurs – simple solution that professional bakers use

When over-proofing occurs, experienced bakers often recommend the following simple solutions;

These are all great ways of preventing over-proofed dough from becoming too dense and heavy when baked.

So, Is over proof dough safe for eating?

man rejoicing

Good news! While over-proofed dough may contain high levels of phytic acid, it doesn’t necessarily mean that it isn’t safe to eat. If consumed in very small amounts over a long period of time, over-proofed dough should not pose a significant health risk. Yes! It can still be eaten, but it may not taste as good as dough that has been proofed properly.


Over-proofed dough is not necessarily unsafe to eat as long as it is consumed in small amounts over a longer period of time. However, over-proofing should still be avoided whenever possible due to the negative effects on texture and taste of the final product. By taking preventative measures such as using more resistant flours and controlling fermentation temperatures, bakers can avoid over-proofing and produce high quality baked goods safely.

Related Articles


Using double zero flour for pizza dough

DOUGH ON A METAL BOWL (cold fermentation)

What is cold fermented pizza dough?


How to proof pizza dough?